A new controversy has emerged in Pakistan’s medical education sector as the Punjab Department of Specialised Healthcare and Medical Education has strongly opposed the recent decision to reduce the MDCAT merit threshold for admissions.
The department formally addressed its concerns in a letter to the president of the Pakistan Medical and Dental Council, referring to a notification issued on April 8, 2026. The notification announced a 3 percent reduction in the minimum marks required for admission into MBBS and BDS programs, a move that has triggered debate among education authorities.
The issue was discussed in detail during a meeting of the Provincial Admissions Committee held on April 13. Committee members expressed serious reservations, questioning both the reasoning behind the decision and its potential impact on the quality of medical education in Pakistan.
According to the department’s letter, the primary objective of lowering the MDCAT threshold appears to be filling vacant seats in private medical and dental colleges for the academic session 2025-26. However, the committee argued that such a step prioritizes institutional capacity over educational standards.
This is not the first time such a proposal has been discussed. In 2025, a similar suggestion to reduce the MDCAT passing criteria by 5 percent was rejected after strong opposition from provincial authorities, who had already raised concerns about maintaining merit and transparency.
Recent data further strengthens the committee’s argument. This year, 47,721 candidates appeared in the MDCAT examination in Punjab. Out of these, 39,648 candidates qualified under the 55 percent requirement for MBBS, while 42,048 met the 50 percent eligibility criteria for BDS programs. Despite this, only 7,987 candidates applied for MBBS admissions.
The committee highlighted that the large number of eligible candidates clearly shows there is no shortage of qualified students. Instead, it pointed to the high fee structure in private medical and dental colleges as the main reason why many students choose not to apply.
Another important concern raised by the committee was related to procedural transparency. Members noted that the decision to reduce the merit threshold was not reviewed by the Academic Board before being presented to the full council, which goes against standard policy-making procedures.
Based on these concerns, the Provincial Admissions Committee unanimously rejected the proposal. It emphasized that lowering the MDCAT merit criteria could compromise the quality of future healthcare professionals, ultimately affecting the overall standard of medical services in the country.
This situation reflects a deeper issue within Pakistan’s education system, where balancing accessibility and quality remains a constant challenge. Experts believe that instead of lowering merit standards, authorities should focus on addressing structural issues such as affordability and transparency to ensure fair and quality medical education for all.
About The Author
